Write an essay to compare and contrast the key arguments from the debate whether immigration should be restricted.

In the early 20th century Americans debated hotly whether immigration should be restricted. Read through the documents below and then, in an essay of 1000-1500 words, compare and contrast the key arguments they contain for and against immigration restriction. Overall, which side you think presents a better case? You should have at least three specific areas of disagreement (argument and counter-argument).